Litigation-I Win, You Lose vs. Mediation-Win/Win

Image
  Litigation is a zero-sum game.  It destroys relationships and fosters enmity between the parties.  Parties rarely walk away happy.  Even if they win, the expense of litigation is enormous, and collecting on judgments is difficult. Disputes ultimately resolve, but the focus on winning at any cost can lead to prolonged legal battles.  Living with a lawsuit causes ongoing stress, which can distract you from your business and even have an effect on your health. In a courtroom, the final decision lies with a judge or jury who may not fully grasp the complexities of the case. Parties relinquish control over the outcome, potentially leaving them dissatisfied with the final judgment. Mediation has the opposite effect.   Rather than polarizing people, it enables the parties to attack the issues and not each other.     The process promotes open communication, collaboration and problem-solving, which enables parties to actively participate in crafting mutually beneficial solutions.   It res

TEN NEW YEAR’S RESOLUTIONS FOR CONTRACTORS-2022

TEN NEW YEAR’S RESOLUTIONS FOR CONTRACTORS-2022

 

Can you say COVID fatigue?  As I sit here to write this year’s resolutions, I can’t believe that coronavirus is still very much with us.  In fact, you can just read my newsletter from last year, and all of them are still relevant. The difference this year is how divided we have become.  Some are living life as it is more or less normal, and others are still playing it safe.  One thing is certain.  The virus has disrupted construction and the way you do business.  On the positive front, I keep hearing that business has never been better.  On the negative side, there are still issues with increases in the cost of materials, shipping delays and unavailability of subcontractors.  Last year I wrote a number of blog posts with clauses to add to your contracts and refined them as new developments occurred. See, http://buildingconfidence-llc.blogspot.com/2020/04/coronavirus-and-construction-clauses.html  Those clauses still hold.  That said, here are the takeaways and goals for 2022:

 


1.     Include the Right to Delay or Cancel Jobs in Your Contracts Before They Start.

Your contract should allow you to delay or cancel jobs before they start depending upon unforeseen circumstances.  Construction jobs are taking longer than expected and new projects may be delayed.  Owners need to be flexible about start dates right now.  You don’t want to have to lose a large job if you’ve run out of time to complete a smaller one.  So, you need a provision in your contracts to protect you if any of those events occur.

 

2.     Include the Right to Delay or Cancel Jobs in Your Contracts Once They Are Under Way.

Workers might be exposed or become ill with coronavirus.  The same can happen with owners.  All sides should have the right to cancel or delay jobs at any time.  Although many contracts have had “force majeure” or “acts of God” clauses, these may not be enough to protect you if you have to press pause on a project.  Review the language in your contracts and add more if necessary.

 

3.     Allow for Increased Material Costs.

The supply chain has been disrupted.  As a result, the costs of materials have been increasing.  Insert a clause in your contract that allows for a change order if costs increase by more than x%.  You should educate owners in advance about this possibility and discuss options for substitutions so there are no surprises.  In addition, if the cost of the job increases too much, you might want to allow for a reduction in scope.

 

4.     Termination for Convenience.

Traditionally residential contracts have not included terminations for convenience, but if you decide that both sides have the right to exercise this option, you will want to put in how much notice you require (seven days?).  Add the remaining payment that would be due, such as payment for all work completed to date plus the cost of demobilization and any work required to protect and preserve the site.

 

5.     Form Strong Relationships with Your Subcontractors.

I have received numerous reports this year about subcontractors delaying or abandoning jobs.  You need to develop strong, consistent relationships with your subs so they are loyal to you.  Pay them fairly and set reasonable expectations.  In subcontractor contracts you can include bonuses for early completion or penalties for delay.  I prefer the former.  It is an excellent selling point with customers to be able to state that you have a reliable pool of subcontractors.  Treat them well.

 

6.     Make Sure You Have Current, Complete Insurance Coverage

I have seen a few nightmare scenarios this year where clients have gotten sued and they either haven’t had liability insurance or their policy didn’t cover the claim.  One of the most important parts of being insured is that your insurance company will provide you with a defense (pay for your lawyer) if you are sued.  They may do so with a “reservation of rights,” which means they may not ultimately cover your claim, but attorney’s fees are incredibly expensive and having them covered is much less stressful than paying out of pocket.  You also need to check your policies with your agent.  A client was sued and discovered his policy didn’t cover construction work on condominiums.  That exclusion made no sense for his business!

 

7.     Review Payment Schedules

Every year I remind people to review their payment schedules.  Given the volatility of the world these days, it seems as though I have recorded more mechanic’s liens than usual.  Cash flow is incredibly important.  In residential home improvement work you have the right to ask for a deposit as long as it is no more than one-third of the contract price or the cost of special-order materials, whichever is greater.  Since you can’t expect final payment until the owner is satisfied with the work, make the final payment really small!

 

8.     Don’t Miss the Window to Record a Mechanic’s Lien

Mechanic’s liens are an incredible tool for getting paid.  They give the contractor or subcontractor leverage in negotiating with owners or GC’s.  People hate having liens on their property and they interfere with the ability to sell, refinance, disburse or secure loans.  If you are a GC, you have no more than 90 days from the last day you worked at the property to record a lien.  If you are a subcontractor, the deadline is usually longer-90 days from the last day anyone working through the GC at the project could record a lien.  Don’t wait.  Liens are very inexpensive (I do them for a flat fee) and if you miss the deadline, you lose the opportunity to record.

 

9.     Consider a “Hold a Spot” Deposit        

Contractors have customers lined up to secure their services.  If you are going to set aside a date for an owner, consider asking for a deposit to hold that spot for them.  You have the right to make some or all of it non-refundable; especially if you are providing design or pre-construction services.  People place value on services they pay for.  A deposit is a way of showing that they are serious about proceeding with their project.

 

10. Include Arbitration and/or Mediation Clauses in Your Contracts

The courts just suspended jury trials until the end of the month.  Litigation is still delayed and lawyers have no control over court schedules.  Lawsuits should always be avoided, but now, more than ever, it’s time to seek out alternative forms of dispute resolution.  As someone who has been doing this for over thirty years, I can tell you that most cases eventually settle rather than going through trial (which is ridiculously expensive), so why waste so much time and money on going through the court system?  Mediation is a voluntary process where the parties work with a third-party neutral to try to resolve their dispute.  It can be very effective in resolving disputes and gives you a say in the outcome.  Arbitration is a private process where an arbitrator acts as the judge and rules on your dispute.  It is usually a binding process and the arbitration decision or award is enforceable by the courts.  The downside of arbitration is that it is almost never appealable.  That said, most parties do not appeal court decisions because the cost of appeals is quite high.

 

 

We are all hoping that 2022 will allow us to go back to our lives.  That said, we all need to continue to adjust to the new normal and adapt our businesses as the work environment changes.  I wish you all a happy and healthy new year!

 

* Andrea Goldman has launched Beyond Dispute Arbitration and Mediation Services. Contact Andrea if you are looking for an arbitrator or mediator for your construction dispute.  Email me your contracts and I will review them for free!  I will then quote you a price for updating them or drafting new ones.  agoldman@goldmanlg.com

 


Popular posts from this blog

Eligibility Requirements for the LEED Green Associate Exam from Green Building Education and Training

EPA Starts Assessing Fines for RRP Violations

Should a Contractor Have the Homeowner Test for Lead?